Albrecht von Graefe, the Suction Method, and the History of Medicine
Albrecht von Graefe went down in history as a physician who consistently advocated a factbased medicine grounded in statistics and experiment. Sometimes, however, it is precisely this forward-looking orientation that leads to premature conclusions.
Coremorphosis is the operative technique by which one seeks to create an artificial pupil. Various techniques existed for this purpose, which Graefe presents in his operative course of 1855. Of the technique of iridodialysis, for instance, he explains briefly that it carries too many risks. All conceivable indications for an iridodialysis can be better treated by iridectomy. Iridectomy is, incidentally, the procedure with which Graefe treated glaucoma and became world-famous.
On iridodialysis he concluded: "Ectomy is able to afford even wholly marginal pupils, and if this is the case, if no indication for dialysis remains, then we shall not hesitate to consign it, together with all its fine-sounding satellites, to history." Graefe thus wishes to relegate this technique to the books of medical history, on the grounds that it was outdated and not successful enough.
Elsewhere Graefe speaks of cataract operations. Here, in the course of my research, I found the following passage: "The suction method is an aberration of operative ophthalmology. Cataracts suited to such an operation are best removed by linear extraction, which is nowhere near as injurious." The suction method in this form proved difficult to identify.
In this connection I found a contribution by the French surgeon and professor Stanislas Laugier in the Annales d'oculistique of 1848.
There he wrote: "In the year 1847 I published a treatise on a new method of cataract operation. It consists in the aspiration of the fluid components by means of a hollow needle fitted with a pump body and a piston." (I thank Anna-Lisa Schmidt for the translation.)
What is at issue, then, are ways of aspirating the cataract — methods that Graefe terms aberrations. What may perhaps have held true at the time is quite otherwise today. The standard nowadays lies in phacoemulsification: the lens nucleus is fragmented with an ultrasound probe and subsequently aspirated, before an artificial lens can be implanted.
Can a direct line be drawn from the suction method of the mid-nineteenth century to phacoemulsification? Hardly. It does show us, however, that even Graefe was not always able to foresee the future correctly.
Conclusion:
Graefe's view that patients should be operated on by the methods demonstrably best corresponds exactly to the demands of evidence-based medicine. Yet perhaps we thereby forgo suggestions to pursue other paths as well, if, like Graefe, we transfer them to the realm of history. Knowledge and experience are also unmistakably lost (one example here would be forceps delivery in obstetrics, which fewer and fewer physicians today have mastered).
Herein, too, may lie the strength of medical history: not only in remembering, but also in giving new impulses and suggestions. In Graefe's day a method employing ultrasound was not to be thought of, but with new technologies old ideas may perhaps regain currency.
